Skip to content

rt-replication-package

Assembles and validates the Data-Editor replication package against the target venue's data-and-code policy — master script, pinned environment, README/roadmap, restricted-data plan, script-to-exhibit output map, and a Data-Editor-grade checklist.

Category: replication
Field: general
License: MIT
Updated: 2026-07
Stages: replication · dissemination

Replication Package (rt-replication-package)

The step that now blocks acceptance at the top (AEA / JF / Management Science Data Editors re-run your code and check every number). Full manifest + validation checklist: shared-resources/empirical-methods/replication-package.md.

When to trigger

  • Approaching final submission, or a conditional accept with a data-and-code requirement.
  • A Data Editor / verification service needs the package.

What it does

  1. Read the venue policy from the target pack's resources/official-source-map.md (code at submission vs. acceptance? Data Editor? AsCollected page? restricted-data rule? hosting?). Match it exactly.
  2. Assemble the manifest: master script (raw → all exhibits), ordered steps (clean → construct → estimate → robustness → tables), pinned environment, README/roadmap, data (or pseudo/synthetic data for restricted access + access instructions), the script→exhibit output map, and the disclosure statement.
  3. Validate with the checklist: runs clean end-to-end on a fresh machine; every reported number reproduced (body + appendix); seeded/deterministic; restricted-data plan; output map complete; venue policy satisfied.

Hard rules

  1. Every reported number traces to a script step (body and appendix).
  2. Deterministic — pin versions, seed RNGs.
  3. Restricted data → pseudo/synthetic data + access instructions, never confidential data committed.
  4. Match the venue's exact policy from the source-map; re-verify before submission.
  5. Keep it in sync with the execution bridge — when a revision re-runs an estimate, regenerate the affected outputs.

Output format

Text Only
【Venue policy】(code timing, Data Editor, restricted-data rule, hosting)
【Manifest】master · steps · env · README · data · output-map · disclosure — status each
【Validation】end-to-end ✓/✗ · all numbers reproduced ✓/✗ · seeded ✓/✗ · restricted-data plan ✓/✗
【Blocking gaps】what would fail a Data-Editor check, ranked
【Ready?】GO / NOT-YET — deciding items

Anti-patterns

  • "Works on my machine" (absolute paths, unpinned versions, manual steps); reported numbers the script doesn't reproduce; committing confidential data; leaving assembly to post-accept crunch.